STATE OF TASMANIA v MATTHEW ROYCE WADLEY 16 NOVEMBER 2026
COMMENTS ON PASSING SENTENCE CUTHBERTSON J
Matthew Royce Wadley, you have pleaded guilty to an indictment charging you with four counts of Criminal Code assault. These assaults were committed by you on 25 January 2025. You were 33 years old at the time. The complainant was aged 15. You engaged in a terrifying and degrading course of conduct towards the complainant. The first count relates to you holding a knife to her throat while saying words to the effect, “If you don’t start walking, I’ll cut your throat”. The second count relates to tying the complainant’s hands together and pushing her to the back. The third count relates to you cutting the complainant’s hair. The final count is a charge of assaulting the complainant by throwing petrol over her. The bare particulars of these offences are bad enough, but they are inadequate to convey the full extent of your cruelty towards the complainant.
You had only known the complainant since 7 January 2025. You knew her father. On that day, you the complainant messaged each other over Facebook messenger. You initiated that contact, claiming you were looking for the complainant’s dad and pressed the wrong button. You asked the complainant if she was the “shawty” who you had seen that day. In the course of that conversation, the complainant told you that she was only 15 years old. You commented that she looked at least 18, that her dad was a mate, and that if she had any troubles, to let you know.
The complainant attended your seven year old son’s birthday party on 11 January 2025 at your house. She asked to stay the night because bad things were happening at her home. She sent you a video which showed her father being assaulted at his home. From between 11 and 25 January, the complainant stayed in your house and slept in your bedroom. The two of you kissed, cuddled and held hands over that time. She considered that the two of you were in a boyfriend/girlfriend relationship.
During this period, you began to become suspicious that the complainant was pregnant. You believed that she had fallen pregnant prior to staying at your house and you thought that you were being “set up” as the father to the child. You tried to make her take a pregnancy test and researched matters relating to pregnancy and morning sickness. On one occasion, you videoed the complainant while telling her to take a pregnancy test. You can be heard saying to the complainant, “Hey drink that water up, so you can test. I reckon you know though, don’t ya, that’s why you’ve been so quiet”.
You spoke about this with friends. I was provided details of a series of messages you exchanged with a contact “Lynden Grice” between 22 and 25 January 2025. On 22 January, you told Mr Grice that if the complainant tested positive, she could “GTFO” meaning “get the fuck out”. You told him that you believed the complainant was pregnant and was setting things up to make it appear that you were the father. You continued messaging Mr Grice in similar vein on 23 January 2025. The messages then took a sinister turn. You referred to a “mountain trip” and commented that “accidents happen”. You also referred to a “bruny mish” and stated, “Leave her at the lighthouse”. You referred to the complainant as a “thot”, which I understand to mean “that ho over there”. You said, “She can suffer the pain”. Mr Grice suggested “somewhere more remote” because the complainant would “probably just whore her way back lol”. You agreed, and responded, “more like Gordon dam or on that dirt road between Orford”. In another message you said, “wish I knew on the mountain trip would a pushed it off the rocks rather than helping it [laughing face emojis] lessons learnt”. You also messaged other people, including the complainant’s brother, telling them you believed that the complainant was pregnant to another male. In these messages, you refer to the complainant as “a thot”, a “dirty slut” and a “slapper”.
You continued to communicate with Mr Grice in the following days by sending a number of audio messages to him. Although the audio messages cannot be accessed, the State asserts they were to the effect that you were contemplating violence against the complainant, as Mr Grice responds, “Lol well hopefully there no need for horror but if that what they want it to be what they will go through”. Mr Grice asked you if you would come to his house after dropping the complainant off or telling her to fuck off. You responded, “I’ll drop it off bowen then come to urs” referring to dropping the complainant off the Bowen Bridge. The two of you discussed getting rid of the complainant’s phone in case it contained material to “use against” you. Your consistent reference to the complainant in derogatory terms and as “it”, and the casual way in which you discussed causing her violence is difficult to read, let alone comprehend.
On 25 January 2025, the complainant was at your house. You looked at your son’s phone and saw a video that showed the complainant saying words like, “Shh, he’s here” as she was moving a curtain aside and looking out the window. You became angry and went through the complainant’s phone. You did not find anything; however, you used a banking application on her phone to take $680 from the complainant’s father and said that it would teach him a lesson. The complainant’s sister called her at 11.52am that day. She had been with her father and had seen the money transferred from his account to an account under the name of Royce Wadley. She knew that their father’s bank account was accessible from the complainant’s phone and she called the complainant to have a go at her for this. The complainant did not speak much during that call.
You told the complainant that you were going to kill her and said things to her like, “You’re going somewhere and you’re never coming back”. You told the complainant to go to your car and get in while saying similar things to her. You followed the complainant to the car. You took knives with you. One was a large black knife and the other was a smaller kitchen knife. They were in your bag which you put in the passenger side of the car. The complainant got into the back seat. You locked the doors. You drove to New Norfolk. You and the complainant talked as you drove. While you did not speak angrily, the complainant felt scared by what you had said earlier. You stopped at a petrol station close to New Norfolk. The complainant remained in the car. You then drove to the river at New Norfolk. The two of you walked to the river together. You were angry and accused the complainant of putting drugs in your drink. You told her, “Your family isn’t going to see you ever again”. The complainant made a phone call to her sister. You hung up the phone and threw it into the river.
The two of you got back in the car. You continued to drive. You smoked methylamphetamine while you were driving. You went to a second petrol station at Bushy Park at 1.09pm and bought more petrol and two cans of coke while the complainant stayed in the car. You got back in the car and locked the doors. You continued to drive. You were singing and smoking while driving. There was some talking between the two of you. At first, you were laughing and smiling and saying that you liked the complainant and then you again accused her of putting drugs in your drink and said words like “This is the last time you are going to see anything ever again”. You told the complainant that you were driving to find a good place to set her on fire so nobody would know what had happened.
You drove to bushland near Franklin. You got out of the car and told the complainant to get out and start walking. She started walking down the road. When she stopped, you put the kitchen knife to her throat. While you were pushing it into her throat, the complainant used her finger to stop it. A car was approaching and you put the knife down. You then told the complainant, “If you don’t start walking, I’ll cut your throat”. You told the complainant to walk to a ditch. She begged you not to make her and asked whether there was a way she could get out alive. You told her, “No”. She must have been absolutely terrified. You told her to get down on her knees in the ditch. She complied. At that point, a woman came out of the house nearby and told you that you were on private property. The two of you then walked back to the car. You continued to drive. During this part of the drive, you unlocked the car and told the complainant to jump out while you were driving. The car was not moving very fast at the time but the complainant did not jump out of the car.
You then drove up Maxfields Road at Franklin and pulled the car over. The two of you got out of the car. You retrieved a black cord from a headset from the boot. You threw the headset into the bush nearby. You then retrieved a red jerry can of petrol from the boot. A witness, who drove by in this period, saw the jerry can near the car. You told the complainant to put her hands behind her back and you tied them together tightly. She was standing at this point. You pushed her to the back forcing her to her knees. You then cut the complainant’s hair with the kitchen knife. As you did so, you said words to the effect of “Let’s see how boys like you now”. You then used the kitchen knife to cut the cord tying the complainant’s wrists. You filled the car with petrol from the jerry can and then poured the rest of the petrol onto the complainant over the top of her head. You told her to start walking down the hill. You got into the car and drove a little way and then pulled over and told her to take her clothes off. You used the kitchen knife to cut up the jumper she was wearing, before putting her clothes into the boot of the car and driving off. The complainant was left to walk down the road in her bra and underpants.
A witness, who was driving his car through the area shortly before 5.30pm, saw you driving down Maxfields Road. He then saw the complainant walking down the road only wearing underpants and a bra. The complainant approached the witness and asked for clothes. The complainant told him that her ex-boyfriend had dropped her off and taken her clothes. The witness gave the complainant his shirt and she asked if he could take her to Glenorchy. He said that he would get her clothes and take her to Huonville.
When the complainant got into the car, the witness could smell petrol. He asked if she had a phone and she told him that you had thrown it into the river. She told him that you had poured petrol on her, threatened to cut her up and burn her, and that she had been in the area for five to ten minutes before he arrived. The witness saw a police car and flagged it down. The police transported the complainant to the Huonville Police Station. Arrangements were made for forensics to attend and for the complainant to provide a video recorded statement. Forensic photographs were taken. It is apparent from those photos that the complainant’s hair was markedly short on one side when compared to the other.
Police attended Maxfields Road and located cut up pieces of black cord and cut up pieces of the complainant’s hair on the side of the road. The area smelt strongly of fuel.
You were located at 7.40pm returning to your home in Glenorchy. You were arrested. Your car was searched. A meat cleaver was located in the front passenger footwell of the car. A knife in a sheath was found in the boot of the car. Various clothing items were also found in the car. One of the clothing items, a black boob tube crop top, appeared to be cut. An Ice pipe and crystalline drug material were also found in the car. No other items of clothing belonging to the complainant were located in the vehicle. It was noted that the car smelt of fuel, but no jerry cans were located.
Subsequent forensic examination of the complainant’s underpants and bra showed the presence of weathered petrol on both items. Items of your clothing returned a result for petrol or weathered petrol. A blood sample was taken from you and showed the presence of methylamphetamine.
You participated in a video recorded interview. Although you provided a number of no comment responses throughout the course of your interview, you also falsely claimed to have been home cleaning, driving back and forth from mates’ places, and that you believed the complainant was 18 to 19 years old. You denied the allegations that were put to you. You said that you believed you had been “roofied” and that you could not remember things from the day as it was a bit of a blur.
I have received a victim impact statement from the complainant. She was absolutely terrified by your conduct on the day. The things you said and the way that you behaved gave her real cause to believe that she would be seriously hurt, if not killed. When you threw her phone into the river, her fear increased as she realised she no longer had the means to contact others to seek help. Your crimes have had a significant impact upon her. Her sleep has been affected. She experiences ongoing nightmares. Some nights, she stays up all night, just to avoid falling asleep as a way of avoiding them. She is always tired as a consequence, which affects other areas of her life. She has struggled to eat properly since the assaults which has led to her losing a significant amount of weight. She had to replace her mobile phone after you threw it in the river. She stays home more now and does not like going outside unless she is with somebody else. She is fearful of encountering you or one of her friends. She has noticed her personality has changed and she finds it easy to become angry. She is unable to understand why this has happened. Her statement powerfully articulates, without embellishment in my view, the terrible harm you have caused her.
You have relevant prior matters. Of particular relevance are family violence offences relating to a former partner committed between 2018 and 2021. They include one count of common assault and many breaches of various forms of family violence order. One of the breach allegations related to you threatening to burn down your former partner’s house and car. You also have a charge of unlawfully administering a drug to your former partner by causing her to take WD-40, a matter that I consider to be particularly concerning. You have received periods of imprisonment for such offending; some of those sentences have been partially or wholly suspended. The balance of your prior matters include multiple occasions of drug driving, other drug offences, drive while disqualified, breach of bail, multiple counts of unlawfully possess a dangerous article in a public place, aggravated assault and other firearm offences. In December 2025, after you committed these offences, you were sentenced to a total period of seven months’ imprisonment for firearms offences, evade police, drug offences, drug driving, unlawfully possess a dangerous article in a public place, fail to appear and for breaching suspended sentences and the conditions of an undertaking. Of the offences that were not the subject of breach proceedings, most were committed after this offence. It is apparent that your use of drugs, particularly methylamphetamine, has a close association with your offending.
You are now 35 years old. You were raised by your mother. Your childhood in that environment was marked by considerable instability and included witnessing serious family violence being perpetrated against your mother. You completed education to year 11. Your mother died in 2012 after a short illness. Although you had difficult experiences in her care, she was an important figure in your life and you found it difficult to cope after her death. You began using illicit substances, particularly methylamphetamine. As your use increased, so did your offending. You have previously held employment, including as a baker, where you partially completed an apprenticeship. You have two children from your former relationship with the victim of your family violence offences. Despite that family violence history, she remains supportive of you. When not in custody, you are actively involved in your children’s lives. You are fortunate to have had the support of your grandparents who are prosocial and positive figures in your life. They have assisted you and your children over the years. Your grandfather was recently diagnosed with vascular dementia. His condition has deteriorated and he has had to go into care. This has been distressing for you and your grandmother. You were made the subject of a community correction order late last year which had a supervision component. I am told that you attended the majority of your appointments and maintained contact with your probation officer. You were on the wait list to undertake the EQUIPS Addiction program. You are yet to engage in meaningful interventions to address your drug use and your childhood experiences. It was submitted on your behalf that you have genuine prospects of rehabilitation.
Your bail was revoked in relation to this matter. I have been told that for backdating purposes the appropriate date to utilise is 5 October 2026. You have pleaded guilty to these offences, but your pleas of guilty came at a late stage. The matter was listed for trial earlier this year. It was unable to proceed at that time due to a key witness being unavailable. A special hearing was then arranged for the purpose of taking the complainant’s evidence instead. For reasons principally related to your conduct, the special hearing was unable to proceed. Your plea came after your bail was revoked and in the face of a strong prosecution case. Although your pleas have avoided the need for the complainant to give evidence, she had been briefed to do so and had attended Court for that purpose.
I am told that you acknowledge the seriousness of your offending and the impact on the complainant. Your conduct was extremely disturbing. You put a young person through a terrifying experience over a number of hours for no rational reason. The messages you exchanged with Mr Grice demonstrate that you had thought about punishing the complainant in some way, and contemplated inflicting violence upon her, for a number of days before embarking on this awful course of conduct. This was not impulsive offending. The degrading way in which you spoke about the complainant with your friends is also distressing. It is, however, consistent with the way in which you ultimately behaved towards her. Although your use of physical violence was limited, this does not diminish the seriousness of your offending. Your conduct towards the complainant was sustained, psychologically cruel and intended to terrify her. Dowsing her in fuel put her at significant risk of physical harm. No explanation has been provided for your offending. I can only infer that your drug use contributed to your paranoid and irrational thoughts about her. While this was not, strictly speaking, a family violence offence, it shares many of its characteristics. The complainant thought that she was in a relationship with you. She was much younger than you, and vulnerable, having sought your assistance when things were difficult at home. There was an element of breach of trust involved in your conduct.
I have taken into account your pleas of guilty and personal circumstances. Perhaps your childhood experiences have normalised such awful conduct towards women. But I would be speculating. I have no information before me capable of establishing that those experiences are causative of your conduct or such that they reduce your moral culpability. General and specific deterrence, denunciation and vindication of the complainant are the key sentencing considerations in this case. It is important to send a message to you and others who engage in such terrible behaviour, particularly towards females, young people and other vulnerable people, that there is no place in our community for such conduct. You have had the benefit of sentences designed to encourage your rehabilitation in the past but have not taken advantage of those opportunities. A sentence of imprisonment is only the available option in the circumstances. I cannot discount that you are capable of rehabilitation in the future. I will make a parole eligibility order. It will be for the parole board to determine at some future time if any of the sentence I impose can appropriately be served in the community.
Matthew Royce Wadley, you are convicted of four counts of Criminal Code assault on the indictment. You are sentenced to three years’ imprisonment backdated to 5 October 2026. I order that you be eligible for parole after you have served 18 months of that sentence.