HILLS, C J

STATE OF TASMANIA v MATTHEW ALLAN WARD and

STATE OF TASMANIA v CAMERON JAMES HILLS      12 NOVEMBER 2026

COMMENTS ON PASSING SENTENCE                                 CUTHBERTSON J

Matthew Allan Ward and Cameron James Hills, you have both pleaded guilty to an indictment charging you with a single count of fraud by obtaining fuel from an unmanned petrol station using a stolen fuel card. In the case of Mr Ward, you obtained $77,027 worth of fuel by using this stolen card on 87 occasions between 5 March and 3 April 2024. You are criminally responsible as a principal for this offending. Mr Hills, you aided and/or enabled Mr Ward on 37 of those occasions between 13 March and 3 April 2024 by driving him to the petrol station and assisting him to obtain the fuel, knowing that the use of the card was dishonest. $41,029.60 worth of the fuel obtained relates to those 37 occasions.

At the time of this offending, you were both living at Mr Ward’s home. The fuel card that was used belonged to a business operating in Hobart. Mr Ward knew a person who had recently stopped working for the business. This person owed Mr Ward approximately $50. He told Mr Ward about a fuel card in one of the trucks belonging to the business that was parked in West Hobart and provided the PIN. It was understood that Mr Ward would use the card to obtain some diesel or would milk fuel from the truck to satisfy the debt. On 4 March 2024, a driver employed by the business noticed the truck he drove had been siphoned of diesel. He also noticed the fuel card that was kept in the truck was missing. This was reported to the owner of the business who made enquiries of other employees to see if the fuel card had been placed in another vehicle. Nothing further was done about that card at that time.

Between 5 March 2024 and 3 April 2024, the stolen card was used to obtain fuel from Tas Petroleum’s unmanned petrol station in Moonah. In April 2024, Tas Petroleum noticed that the diesel stock at the petrol station was low. The diesel transactions were reviewed and it was noted that the business had used $86,000 worth of diesel in March 2024. When the business was contacted to confirm whether this was accurate, Tas Petroleum was advised of the suspected theft of the fuel card. They reviewed their records and confirmed all transactions were made against the stolen fuel card utilising various pumps at the Moonah site. A stop was placed on the card, and the matter was reported to Tasmania police on 4 April 2024.

Tasmania police reviewed CCTV footage from the petrol station. Your involvement in these offences was captured on that footage. On 5 March 2024, Mr Ward went to the petrol station in an SUV.  $99.31 worth of fuel was pumped into the car by Mr Ward. The same car returned to the petrol station two more times that day. On each of those occasions, the fuel card was used by Mr Ward to operate the pumps to fill containers located in the boot of the SUV. Over $600 worth of fuel was obtained on those subsequent occasions.

Mr Ward attended the fuel station on 24 further days, often on multiple occasions. For example, on 9 March 2024, there were six separate attendances. Mr Hills was involved in attendances occurring over the course of 15 separate days. The fuel card was used to fill large containers, including 200 litre drums and 1000 litre intermediate bulk containers. On some of those days, significant amounts of fuel were obtained. For example, on each of 17, 23, 29, 30 and 31 March 2024, over $5,000 worth fuel was obtained. On a number of occasions, two pumps were used to fill up the containers more efficiently. It is apparent from the footage that Mr Ward attempted to disguise his appearance by wearing face coverings, hats and glasses, and, on some occasions, a wig.

The two of you were intercepted by police on 16 April 2024 travelling in a ute. Your clothing and appearance were consistent with that observed in the CCTV footage obtained from the Moonah petrol station. Mr Ward’s house was searched that same day. A number of containers and items of clothing were located which were also consistent with items observed in the CCTV footage.  A long black wig, that looked like the one worn by one of the offenders on a number of occasions, was also found.

You were both interviewed by police. Mr Hills, you admitted using a fuel card that had been given to Mr Ward to fill up containers. You told police that the diesel you obtained was sold to others and that you got some money out of it. Mr Ward, you admitted being the person depicted in a picture taken at the petrol station on 23 March 2024. You admitted using the pump to transfer diesel and using a fuel card given to you by a “bloke” that worked for the business. You claim to have been told you could use the card to get as much fuel as you wanted. You also claim the person who provided the card was involved in distributing the fuel after it had been obtained. You said you did not receive much money for doing this. You told police that you just thought you were helping out the person who gave you the card with his business. You said you were just getting fuel for them and thought they were doing it on insurance or claiming tax.

You were both initially charged on 17 April 2024 with 100 counts of using a computer with intent to defraud and two counts of stealing. Mr Ward pleaded not guilty to those charges and first appeared in this Court on 23 July 2024. Mr Hills pleaded not guilty on 6 September 2024 and made a preliminary proceedings application. He first appeared in this Court on 29 April 2025. Mr Hills pleaded guilty on 31 July 2026. Mr Ward pleaded guilty on 14 August 2026. The matters have ultimately resolved in a manner consistent with a proposal put by the State in April 2026. I requested extended pre-sentence and home detention assessment reports in relation to you both after your pleas were entered.

Mr Ward, you were 32 years old when you committed this offence. You had a dysfunctional upbringing. You were exposed to alcohol and drug abuse and experienced homelessness from a young age. Your parents were not consistent caregivers. Both had significant substance abuse issues. You had a stronger relationship with your father. He died in 2024. Your mother died in 2015.

You have five children from a previous relationship. All of your children are in the care of the State. I was told you have some involvement with your youngest child and are working with services with a view to more contact, if not reunification, with all of your children. This information was not correct. The “youngest child” is not your child, but the son of your current partner. Enquiries have confirmed that you are currently having no contact with Child Safety Services in respect of your own children. Your relationship with your former partner was characterised by mutual substance use and family violence. You have been in your current relationship for five years. Your formal education ended after completing year eight. You completed a metal fabrication qualification while in prison in 2021. You have been employed for periods as a labourer since you were 16.

You have had your own struggles with substance abuse. You commenced using cannabis when 16, ceasing in 2020. You were a heavy drinker from age 13. You have not drunk since you were 18. You have also used methylamphetamine since you were 15. Your use of that substance has been very significant at times, including when you were engaged in this offending. You report having used methylamphetamine on three occasions in the last eight months. Your reduction in use coincides with your engagement with The Hive. You have also been receiving opiate replacement therapy for several years. You have recently obtained an ABN and have started a maintenance business.

You have a significant history of prior offending commencing as a youth. Dishonest offending has regularly featured in your record of prior convictions since 2017. You have been sentenced to terms of imprisonment and community correction orders. In 2017 and 2018, you were sentenced to a total of 26 months’ imprisonment for numerous serious driving, dishonesty, firearms and violent offences. The period of imprisonment imposed included the activation of suspended sentences.  In 2021, you were sentenced to 16 months’ imprisonment and a community correction order for a range of dishonesty, family violence, firearm, driving and drug offences.  By my calculation, the offending for which you fall to be sentenced by me was committed within two years of your release from prison. Since committing this offence, you have been sentenced to home detention in the Magistrates Court for dishonesty, driving and bail offences. Much of the dishonest offending was committed within a similar time frame as this offence. Within four months of the home detention order being imposed, it was reviewed and extended. Ultimately, the order was revoked in April 2025 at which time you were resentenced to a partially suspended period of imprisonment.

Community Corrections have assessed you as unsuitable for a further home detention order. The report outlines that you were initially breached due to taking measures to obscure your movements and mask your electronic monitoring device. You were breached a second time on that order for returning consistently positive drug tests and other non-compliance issues. In addition, Community Corrections outlined that your response to various community correction orders imposed between 2012 and 2021 indicated poor compliance. Your previous engagement with community-based orders was discussed with you during the assessment process. You reported you were not previously ready to actively participate in change and that matters, such as your father’s death and consistent substance use, contributed to this non-compliance. You accept you have no one to blame but yourself for that non-compliance. You were assessed as suitable for community service. You are also assessed as requiring a very high level of intervention, demonstrating several areas of criminogenic risk, namely substance use, employment, lack of prosocial supports, and antisocial attitudes. As a consequence, Community Corrections have assessed you as suitable for community-based supervision. If such an order were made, case management would focus on you maintaining your engagement with child safety and substance counselling services. Community Corrections consider you would benefit from structured support in relation to your substance use issues and related risks. You have also been assessed as suitable to participate in the EQUIPS Addiction program. Since this report was provided, I have received information from Community Corrections indicating you poor compliance with a current community correction order, including not attending the community service roster and issues in relation to being uncontactable.

During the course of the assessment undertaken by Community Corrections, you indicated you believed that what you were doing at the time of the offending was legal as you had been given the PIN. You also said you were under the influence of methylamphetamine which impacted your ability to comprehend the situation. This explanation is difficult to accept in light of the steps you took to try and disguise your appearance at times when you attended the petrol station. You told Community Corrections that you have made changes to your social circle and associates since this offending.

Your counsel urged me to impose a sentence that would not result in an actual period of imprisonment. Emphasis was placed on your current engagement with The Hive and your efforts to address your substance abuse. Your counsel submitted that your rehabilitation has not followed a straight line and had derailed at times due to difficult personal circumstances such as the death of your father.

Mr Hills, you were 36 years old when you committed this offence. You had a stable upbringing and continue to enjoy a close relationship with your family. You completed year 12 before joining the workforce. You had a good employment history as a labourer and landscape gardener. Unfortunately, you suffered a serious workplace injury when you were 21 and were unable to work for three years. You were living in Queensland at the time. You had your first child with you partner shortly after the injury. This was a stressful time for you. You were already a heavy drinker before the injury, but from that time, your use of alcohol became more problematic. You did return to work after you recovered from your injuries. You had two more children with your partner and returned to Tasmania eight years ago. Your relationship with your partner ended shortly after your return. I am told you are on good terms with your former partner and spend regular time with your children. You started using methylamphetamine about four years ago. As your use became more regular, you increasingly associated with others using drugs. You lost your job. You moved into Mr Ward’s house. You were using drugs on a daily basis. You agreed to assist Mr Ward in the context of your addiction and housing situation.

You have a number of prior convictions, but very little history of dishonest offending. Your prior matters consist mainly of drink driving, traffic matters, family violence and related offending. The penalties you have received have principally been fines and disqualification. In November 2020, you were sentenced to a wholly suspended period of imprisonment together with a community correction order including community service for alcohol related driving offences. In 2013, you were sentenced on two counts of burglary and stealing committed in 2006 when you were 18 years old. No convictions were recorded. Since committing the current offence, you have been sentenced to a period of partially suspended imprisonment and a community correction order for drug driving and Bail Act offences and to a wholly suspended period of imprisonment for unlawfully setting fire to a vehicle.

Community Corrections reports that you have demonstrated good compliance to past and current community based orders. You engage well and complete tasks as directed. You are currently participating in the EQUIPS Addiction program which you are due to complete in November. You have largely completed the community service hours you are required to perform through the work roster and participation in the EQUIPS program. You have reported reducing your use of methylamphetamine and no longer consider that you are addicted. You claim to be motivated to become drug free. Community Corrections has assessed you as suitable for a home detention order. If such an order is made, they recommend you be subject to electronic monitoring and prohibited from taking any illicit or prohibited substances. You have also been assessed as suitable for the imposition of a community correction order with community service and supervision.

There are important differences in your respective levels of culpability, prior criminal histories and previous responses to prior community-based orders which warrant different sentencing outcomes.   First, Mr Ward, you fall to be sentenced as a principal for the entirety of the conduct. Mr Hills is to be sentenced for his involvement in less than half of the relevant transactions. Second, Mr Ward’s history of dishonest offending, particularly since 2017, is also concerning. You were involved in other offending around that time, including significant firearms offences. Mr Ward, while you are not to be sentenced for your prior record, this highlights that your conduct on this occasion was not isolated. You have also demonstrated a poor response to community-based orders, breaching suspended sentences on many occasions and failing to comply with the conditions of a home detention order and the current community correction order.

This offending was serious. It was a persistent course of conduct which resulted in unlawfully obtaining a high value of goods. I expect the ease with which you were able to obtain such a valuable product encouraged you to continue. Your offending only ended when a stop was placed on the card. While Mr Hills frankly admitted his involvement in the conduct, Mr Ward, you persisted in suggesting that you did not appreciate at the time that what you were doing was unlawful. This is impossible to reconcile with the pattern of conduct you engaged in, including using items of clothing to disguise your appearance, which strongly suggests you were well aware that your conduct was unlawful. This ongoing lack of insight or willingness to fully acknowledge wrongdoing is relevant to assessing your prospects of rehabilitation. I do not ignore that you have been addressing your drug use, have started a business and have been helping your current partner with her child. You should be encouraged to do these things. While the orders I make will include a period of imprisonment, eligibility for parole coupled with a community correction order will provide that encouragement. I accept you have spent time in custody on this matter already, but it appears to me that all of that time has been allocated to other sentences.

As for Mr Hills, your offending, while less extensive than that of Mr Ward, was also serious. You have experienced being in custody for the first time, and I accept that has been a wake up call for you. That time has all been allocated to another sentence. You have good support in the community and have demonstrated compliance with the conditions of community-based orders. I accept this offence formed part of a relatively isolated course of conduct you engaged in during a period you were struggling with recent drug addiction. You have taken steps to address your issues and rebuild relationships with positive people who support you to do the right thing. I would have imposed a sentence of imprisonment, but I have determined it would be appropriate to impose a home detention order. The length of the order is intended to operate as a significant punishment for your conduct and restrict your freedom. You will be confined to your home detention order address for extended periods of time in order to sheet home to you the seriousness of your conduct. There will be strict conditions, and, if they are breached, you will be brought back to Court, and an actual term of imprisonment may be substituted. I will also impose a community correction order with a supervision and community service component.

Mr Ward and Mr Hills, you are both convicted of a charge of fraud.

Mr Ward, you are sentenced to a period of 12 months’ imprisonment from today, backdated to 5 November 2026. I order that you be eligible for parole after serving six months of that sentence. I also make a community correction order for a period of 12 months from your release from custody. That order will be subject to the core conditions of a community correction order set out at s 42AO of the Sentencing Act. They will be provided to you in writing but include that you report to the Hobart office of Community Corrections at 75 Liverpool Street Hobart within two business days of your release from custody. During the operational period of the order, you must not commit an offence punishable by imprisonment, you must report to a probation officer as required by the probation officer, you must comply with the reasonable and lawful directions of a probation officer, you must not leave, or remain outside, Tasmania without the permission of a probation officer and you must give notice to a probation officer of any change of address or employment before, or within two working days after, the change.

In addition, I impose the following special conditions that, during the operational period of the order:

  • You must submit to the supervision of a probation officer as required by the probation officer;
  • You must attend educational and other programs as directed by a probation officer;
  • You must undergo assessment and treatment for drug dependency as directed by a probation officer;
  • You must submit to testing for drug use as directed by a probation officer; and
  • If directed by a probation officer, you must attend, participate in, and complete the EQUIPS Addiction Program as directed.

Mr Hills, you are sentenced to home detention for an operational period of nine months. The home detention order takes effect from today. In addition, I make a community corrections order for a period of 12 months. You will be required to perform 75 hours of community service as part of that order within that 12 month period.

The terms of the home detention and community correction order will be set out in a written document that will be provided to you. All core conditions of the home detention order will be in force for the operational period of the orders. Those core conditions include that you:

  • Must not commit an offence that is punishable by imprisonment;
  • You must reside at the home detention premises, namely **address**;
  • You must be at the home detention premises at all times except between 10am to 3pm Monday to Friday, unless:
  • you are travelling to or from, or are at, premises at which you are seeking urgent medical treatment or dental treatment; or
  • it is necessary to not be on the premises in order to avoid, or minimise a serious risk of, the death of, or injury to, you or another person; or
  • with the approval, of a probation officer or prescribed officer, given –
  • so as to enable you to comply with a special condition; or
  • so as to enable you to seek or engage in employment; or
  • so as to enable you to attend an educational or training course or activity; or
  • so as to enable you to attend a rehabilitative or re-integrative activity or program; or
  • so as to enable you to attend a court; or
  • for any other purpose approved by the probation officer or prescribed officer;
  • You must permit a police officer, probation officer or prescribed officer to enter the home detention premises;
  • You must permit a police officer to –
  • conduct a search of the home detention premises; and
  • conduct a frisk search, within the meaning of the Search Warrants Act 1997 , of you, at the home detention premises or at any other place or premises; and
  • take a sample of a substance found on the home detention premises or on your person;
  • You must comply with any reasonable and lawful directions of a probation officer or prescribed officer, including any directions as to the kind of employment, or the place of employment, of you;
  • You must submit to electronic monitoring including by wearing or carrying an electronic device;
  • You must not, without reasonable excuse, remove, tamper with, damage, disable or interfere with the proper functioning of any device or equipment used for the purpose of electronic monitoring;
  • You must not permit, without reasonable excuse, another person to remove, tamper with, damage, disable or interfere with the proper functioning of any device or equipment used for the purpose of electronic monitoring;
  • You must comply with all reasonable and lawful directions given to you in relation to the electronic monitoring, including in relation to the installation, attachment or operation of a device, or a system, used for the purposes of electronic monitoring by:
    • a police officer;
    • a probation officer or prescribed officer; or
    • another person whose functions involve the installation or operation of a device, or a system, used for the purposes of electronic monitoring.
  • You must, if directed to do so by a police officer, probation officer or prescribed officer, submit to a breath test, urine test, or other test, for the presence of an illicit drug;
  • You must, if directed by a probation officer or a prescribed officer to engage in a personal development activity, counselling, or treatment, engage in the activity, counselling or treatment in accordance with any directions given by the probation officer or prescribed officer.

Your home detention order is also subject to the following special conditions during the operational period of the order:

  • You must attend the Community Corrections office at 3 Terry Street, Glenorchy for induction onto this order no later than 12:00pm on 13 November 2026;
  • You must maintain in operating condition an active mobile phone service, provide the contact details to Community Corrections and be accessible for contact through this device at all times;
  • You must submit to the supervision of a Community Corrections officer as required by that officer;
  • You must not take any illicit or prohibited substances. Illicit and prohibited substances include:
  • Any controlled drug as defined by the Misuse of Drugs Act 2001 (Tas);
  • Any medication containing an opiate, benzodiazepine, bupropion, hydrochloride or pseudoephedrine unless you provide written evidence from your medical professional that you have been prescribed the relevant medication.

Your community correction order is subject to the core conditions of a community correction order set out at s 42AO of the Sentencing Act. They will be provided in writing but include that you report to the Glenorchy office of Community Corrections at 3 Terry Street, Glenorchy no later than 12:00pm on 13 November 2026.  During the operational period of the order, you must not commit an offence punishable by imprisonment, you must report to a probation officer as required by the probation officer, you must comply with the reasonable and lawful directions of a probation officer or supervisor, you must not leave, or remain outside, Tasmania without the permission of a probation officer and you must give notice to a probation officer of any change of address or employment before, or within two working days after, the change. In addition, I impose the following special conditions that, during the operational period of the order:

  • You must submit to the supervision of a probation officer as required by the probation officer;
  • You must within 12 months satisfactorily perform 75 hours of community service as directed by a probation officer or a supervisor;
  • You must attend educational and other programs as directed by a probation officer;
  • You must undergo assessment and treatment for drug dependency as directed by a probation officer; and
  • You must submit to testing for drug use as directed by a probation officer.

I note that there has been an application for compensation in favour of Vero Insurers pursuant to s 68 of the Sentencing Act. I adjourn that application to a date to be fixed.

I also order pursuant to s 11(1)(a) of the Crimes Confiscation of Profits Act 1993 that the following items be forfeited to the State of Tasmania pursuant to s 16 in relation to Mr Ward:

Item 1 from property seizure record 235382.

Items 5, 7 and 8 from property seizure record 172025.