STATE OF TASMANIA v PETER JAMES GOSS 11 NOVEMBER 2026
COMMENTS ON PASSING SENTENCE CUTHBERTSON J
Peter James Goss, you have pleaded guilty to a charge of causing grievous bodily harm. On 12 September 2025, you struck your older brother, Michael Goss, multiple times to the head with the battery end of a torch, causing him serious injuries. You were 65 years old at the time. Your brother was 71 years old. As at the time of this offence, you and your brother would regularly catch up. You would watch the football and movies together, drink and go four-wheel driving on roughly a weekly basis.
On this particular occasion, your brother was visiting you at your house. He was pruning the apple trees on your property when you returned home from work. The two of you then spent the evening in the shed at your home where you watched a movie and the football on TV. You were both drinking beers. You estimate that you drank about 12 stubbies each. You were drinking Cascade Bitter. Although the two of you had generally got along well, there had been some tension since your mother’s death a couple of months earlier. Your brother is the executor of your mother’s estate. Later in the evening, an argument started when discussing matters relating to your mother’s estate. You told your brother to “Fuck off and leave”. You turned off the TV and left the shed, heading to your house. You grabbed a torch as you left to light the way to your house. Your brother grabbed his belongings and went to his car. The two of you continued to argue while he was getting in the car.
Your brother started to reverse out of the driveway. A security camera at your property audio-visually recorded you yelling at your brother as he leaving in his car. You can be heard yelling at him, “You fucking fuck off”. You then made reference to your younger brother “whose fucked”. This is a reference to your younger brother who you did not get on with at the time. Your brother stopped his car, got out and yelled, “Excuse me” and headed in your direction. The security camera did not capture any further part of what then took place. As your brother approached you, you struck him to the head with the battery end of the torch with significant force. He immediately fell to the ground. While he was laying on the ground, you repeatedly struck him to the head and face multiple times with the torch. The complainant lost consciousness. He briefly regained consciousness and, believing you were kicking him, asked you to stop doing so. He lost consciousness again shortly after. It is not asserted that you kicked the complainant at all during the assault.
You stopped the assault and called 000. During the call you admitted hitting the complainant with the torch in your hand, said that there was blood coming out of him everywhere and if he was to get up you would give him more, but you did not want to kill him. While you were on the phone, your brother managed to get to his feet. Police attended. The interactions between the two of you were captured on their body worn camera. Under caution, you said that nothing like this had happened between the two of you before. You claimed that your brother had come at you aggressively and said that you had defended yourself. You admitted that you probably hit him way more than you should have because “my older brother always said how tough he is, so I wanted to make sure he was not going to get up and hurt me”.
The complainant initially refused to be seen by paramedics and was taken by police back to his home. Paramedics attended his property shortly after and transported him to the Royal Hobart Hospital. He received multiple injuries, the most serious of which were the complex mid-face fractures including:
- acute nasofrontal fracture (which is the part of the nose attached to the forehead)
- nasal bone fractures
- anterior nasal spine fracture (where the nose joins the upper jaw)
- bilateral orbital floor fractures
- right lamina papyracea fracture (nose-side of the right eye socket)
- fractures of the right maxilla (the upper jaw)
- left zygoma fracture (cheek bone)
He also had lacerations to his left eyebrow, extensive contusions and subcutaneous emphysema in the mid facial structure, bruising and right anterior third and fourth rib fractures. He underwent surgery on 14 September 2025 to repair the complex midfacial fractures which involved open reduction and internal fixation with multiple plates to both sides of his face, his left eye socket and metal splints sewed into his nose. He was discharged from hospital on 18 September 2025. He has required significant post-operative care and follow up. Since the assault and surgery he continues to experience:
- double vision and pain around the eye which he reports has caused him difficulty in concentrating when reading;
- altered sensation over the forehead and jaw, left-sided facial nerve weakens resulting in a droopy eyelid and reduced lower lip movement, numbness to his top lip and to the side of his nose;
- a nasal deviation resulting in nasal obstruction
- misalignment of the upper and lower teeth meaning affecting his ability to bite and chew food;
- a sunken appearance of the left temple area
- chronic nerve pain around his eyes and headaches;
- a post-traumatic cataract predominantly in his left eye but also in his right eye;
- mental health effects including low mood and loss of confidence due to vision changes.
As at 24 April 2026, further surgery was planned to reconstruct his left orbital floor and reposition his jaw. That surgery occurred approximately four weeks ago. It is not yet known to what extent the further surgery has improved his vision and jaw alignment. I am told he is still on a soft food diet as a consequence of that last lot of surgery. His altered sensation and facial nerve weakness may be temporary or permanent.
You were interviewed by police on 15 October 2025. You made significant admissions. You claimed that the complainant came at you “super aggressively” and you defended yourself, conceding that you obviously overreacted. When shown photographs of the complainant on the night and a photograph of him in hospital, and when told about the injuries that were inflicted, you responded, “I can’t believe I did it to him”.
The fact that you struck your brother in this way and that it resulted in him incurring significant injuries is not controversial. What is controversial is your state of mind at the relevant time. During the course of the initial sentencing hearing, two issues arose. First, the State asserts that you intended to cause grievous bodily harm at the time of delivering the blows. You dispute this and say that you did not intend that result but foresaw the likelihood of that kind of harm being caused. Secondly, you say that when you struck your brother, you were acting in self-defence. You claim that the first blow was lawful but accept that the remaining blows were not reasonable in the circumstances you as you believed them to be.
A disputed facts hearing was conducted on 10 September 2026 to resolve these disputes. The State accept that the onus was on them to prove beyond reasonable doubt that you intended to cause grievous bodily harm to your brother as it is a matter aggravating your culpability. Your claim that you were acting in self-defence at all times, and that the first blow was a lawful use of force for that reason, is a matter which may reduce the gravity of your offending and must be proved by you on the balance of probabilities: R v Olbrich (1999) 199 CLR 270, 281 [27].
The State called one witness, Dr Ankit Garg, a consultant in Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery who performed surgery on your brother on 14 September 2025. A number of exhibits were tendered during the course of the hearing. They were the security camera footage from your property, audio recordings of the 000 phone call you made on the night, body worn camera footage recorded by the police officers who attended your property, photographs of the complainant’s injuries, screenshots of text messages you sent to the complainant in the days after the assault, an audio visual recording of your record of interview with police, a report authored by Dr Garg and Dr Helen Quach about the complainant’s injuries, treatment and prognosis, and medical records concerning your brother from the Royal Hobart Hospital. You also gave evidence on the hearing. Your evidence on the hearing, in my view, was of limited utility in resolving these issues. When pressed about what your brother did in the period immediately prior to and following the delivery of the first blow, what you then did, the amount of force you used and what you were thinking, you essentially stated you did not remember. The only thing you remembered was what you described as the haunting sight of his face which caused you stop your assault. It was, therefore, necessary to principally rely on the other evidence presented during the course of the hearing in order to resolve these issues.
What follows are my reasons for finding:
- The first blow was delivered to the complainant in self-defence, but it was not a reasonable use of force and was not lawful on that basis;
- You did not genuinely believe that you were acting in self-defence when you delivered the subsequent blows; and
- The first blow was not delivered with an intention to cause grievous bodily harm, but the subsequent blows were.
I deal with the self-defence issue first. Section 46 of the Criminal Code provides that a person is justified in using, in the defence of himself, such force as, in the circumstances as he believes them to be, it is reasonable to use. In Walsh v R [1993] TASSC 91, Crawford J (as he then was), with whom Cox J and Zeeman J agreed, explained at [16]:
“Self defence under s46 involves a subjective and an objective test. The subjective test can be said to involve two questions, whether the accused was acting in defence of himself when he used the force in question, and what were the circumstances as he believed them to be which might be taken into account for the purposes of the objective test. The objective test is whether the force used was, in the circumstances as the accused believed them to be, reasonable to use.”
The question that arises under the first limb is whether you really believed there was a situation requiring the use of force in your defence. This requires consideration of what you thought the danger was. The subjective nature of the test accommodates a mistaken belief that force was necessary: R v Williams (1984) 78 CR App R 276, at 281. The assertion is one, however, that falls to be tested by reference to the circumstances. While there is no objective element to the first limb of the test, the reasonableness or otherwise of the belief may well be material to the assessment of whether the belief was held at all: Williams (supra), Beckford v The Queen [1988] AC 130, at 145.
As to the second question, this involves the making of a judgment which takes into account all the circumstances of the situation in which you found yourself. In making that judgement, I recognise “that the circumstances which entitle a person to act in self-defence are not conducive to the making of a cool considered assessment of the amount of force which is appropriate particularly when there has been provocation and that therefore it is unrealistic to weigh such conduct on golden scales”: Connaire v Austin [1988] TASSC 42, Green CJ at [4].
So what did you think the danger was? And what were the circumstances as you believed them to be? In your interview with police, you said that the complainant is about the same height as you, but a bit more solid. You explained that you had never previously been in any sort of physical fight with your brother. In the 000 call, the body warn camera footage and your interview with police, you outlined that discussions about your mother’s house and your brother’s comments about your sister caused you to become upset and led you to ask him to leave. It does not appear that the complainant said anything to you that could be perceived as threatening at that time. You used language such as nit-picking to describe the sorts of things he was saying. You clearly very annoyed.
It is clear that the complainant was in the process of leaving your property. You, however, yelled aggressively at him while he was reversing out his driveway. You claim that you were responding to things he said, but that was not captured by the footage. The complainant did, however, stop his car, get out and approach you. I accept that was the case.
As to what happened at that point, the version of events you have given falls short of any suggestion that your brother attempted to physically assault you. In your interview with police, you said he yelled at you, but
“I don’t know whether he lunged at me, whether he swung at me, I don’t think he had any contact with me but I just, I cracked it with him, I just cracked it and … I hit him with the torch, knocked him onto the ground… And I’m sorry but I pounded the absolute crap out of him with the torch and I suddenly come to my senses and thought fuck and that’s when I rang 000 and said what had happened”.
You explained that he came after you “super aggressively”, that you defended yourself, and “obviously overreacted”. When police asked you what he was doing at the time, you said “I dunno… obviously still yelling at me, I dunno honestly it’s a bit of a blank there”. When you were later asked about the yelling, you said you did not 100% know. You told police that you did not know what happened, but you were obviously “fretting” for your life. You confirmed in the interview that when you hit the complainant the first time, he went straight to the ground and, in your words, “I knocked him out cold”. Police asked you about the level of force you used when you first hit the complainant and to rate it between one and 10, with 10 being “going for gold”. You responded “100%, 10”. You were asked what you thought was going to happen to you if your brother got to you at that time. You stated, “Probably hurt me, he was probably going to pull me eye out”. This was a reference to conversations you said you previously had with the complainant. You claimed that the complainant had previously told you that if you got in a fight and had a young bloke after you, the only way you were going to defeat and save yourself is to hurt them.
You told police you continued to “pound” the complainant with the torch until you suddenly realised “fuck what are you doing sort of thing” and stopped. When asked about the level of force used with the subsequent blows, you told police you did not know but “probably still as fucking hard”. You reiterated that you “snapped, absolutely snapped”.
It is not necessary to outline what you said during the 000 phone call and to police in any more detail. It largely repeats the same propositions. You consistently referred to fearing your brother. You described him as aggressive, but, in my view, struggled to give concrete examples of what caused you to arrive at that conclusion. You also did not assert that your brother did anything overtly threatening or suggestive of an imminent attack apart from approaching you and yelling. You explained to police in your interview that your brother’s conduct had been more aggressive since your mother’s death.
You were clearly upset on the night. I infer that your grief, use of alcohol and issues relating to your mother’s estate had clouded your judgment on the night. I am satisfied on the balance of probabilities that you held a genuine belief that you needed to use force to protect yourself when you delivered the first blow. That belief was unreasonable, but I am satisfied it was subjectively held. I find that you delivered that blow with significant force, which is consistent with what you told police on the night, later in the record of interview, and with it causing the complainant to immediately fall to the ground. A blow of that type towards an unarmed man who had never physically assaulted you throughout your entire life was unreasonable. I am not satisfied on the balance of probability that it was a lawful use of force. As to the remaining blows, I am not satisfied on the balance of probabilities that you genuinely believed you needed to continue to hit the complainant to defend yourself. He was, by that stage, helpless. He presented no continuing threat to you. In fact, I do not accept that you have any independent recollection of what you were thinking from the time of the first blow. You had, using your own words, “snapped” or “cracked it”. Either you were unthinking, or you were acting out of frustration and anger in the context of the matters I have already outlined.
As to the second issue, the starting point is your acceptance that at the time of assaulting your brother, you foresaw the likelihood that grievous bodily harm might be caused. By your plea of guilty, you acknowledge at least turning your mind to the sort of harm that may be caused by your conduct. Grievous bodily harm is defined in s 1 of the Criminal Code as “any bodily injury of such a nature as to endanger or be likely to endanger life, or to cause or be likely to cause serious injury to health”. The State argues that the descriptions you gave of the force you used when striking the complainant, of snapping and cracking it with the complainant, the area of the body you struck, the number of times you did so and the use of a weapon is evidence from which I can infer that you engaged in this conduct with at least an intent to cause serious injury to his health. The evidence given by Dr Garg was to the effect that the type of injury the complainant incurred is generally associated with motor vehicle crashes where a passenger is unrestrained and their face hits a surface at a high velocity. The State says this is further evidence from which an intention to cause serious injury to the complainant’s health can be inferred. By contrast, it was submitted on your behalf that the evidence supports that you had not specifically turned your mind to the sort of injury that may be caused. The difficulty with that submission is that it ignores that by your plea you accept you had at least adverted to the likelihood of such harm being caused. I accept, however, that I need to be careful not to automatically treat statements made by you after the event such as having “smashed the shit out” of the complainant as descriptions of your actual state of mind at the relevant time, as opposed to observations made after the assault of the result of your conduct.
What is more telling, in my view, is the graphic way in which you demonstrated how you “pounded” the torch into the complainant’s head on multiple occasions after he had fallen to the ground. You demonstrated a motion of driving the torch forcefully down upon his head, much like hammering a stake into the ground.
I have considered all of the evidence very carefully. I am not satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the first blow was delivered with intent to at least cause serious injury to the complainant. I have no doubt, however, that the subsequent blows were. They were brutally delivered to a helpless man. In my view, it was clear at that point that you wanted to seriously hurt him in a way likely to cause a serious injury to his health. You may not recall that now, but that is the only reasonable inference available on the evidence.
I have received a victim impact statement from the complainant. He recalls thinking he was going to die during your attack. He describes the terrible physical and emotional impacts of your conduct. He has endured multiple surgeries including to reconstruct the floor of the orbit of his eye and correct his malocclusion. I understand further surgery may be required to correct the post traumatic cataracts. He suffers frequent headaches and has tingling on the left side of his face. The nerves in his face are sending the wrong signals. He has difficulty seeing. He has not worked since the assault. His balance has been affected. He has been experiencing ongoing pain from his injuries. He has had periods of experiencing difficulties sleeping including regular nightmares and flashbacks. He describes feeling hypervigilant when going places and interacting with people. Because of the injuries to his jaw, he was on a soft food diet for a long period of time, and he is back on that diet. He has lost a lot of weight because of this. There have been frequent trips to hospitals for review and treatment which has placed a burden on him. He is devastated that the relationship he had with you has now been totally shattered. The two of you were close and shared a number of interests. He says that he will never be able to have that relationship again. He is also, understandably, angry. His life has changed to such a degree that he does not know if he will ever be able to see himself as a confident, capable, proud man again.
This was an horrendous assault. What makes it so difficult to comprehend is that you have no relevant matters of personal violence. Your record of prior convictions is largely confined to driving matters, including three alcohol related driving offences. The last of those was committed 34 years ago.
You are now 66 years old. You were born and raised in Tasmania and have been a hard-working and productive member of the community for the entirety of your life. Your family life growing up was modest, but a good one. There was no family violence or drug or alcohol abuse in the home. You maintained close ties with at least two of your siblings, including the complainant, well into adulthood. Family is obviously a matter of great importance to you. You were closely involved in caring for your mother in her final years. You provided emotional, practical and financial support to her. You have previously been married but have been single for 20 years. You have an adult daughter who lives in Victoria with her partner and your granddaughter. You moved to Victoria to live with your daughter after this offence. You sold your property and retired. This was a direct consequence of your offending. One of the saddest things about this case is how you have destroyed a part of something that was so important to you, namely your family relationships. I accept that you did not set out to assault your brother in the way that you did. You had the torch on hand for a legitimate reason. I accept that this offending was spontaneous and unpremeditated.
You are someone who is generally in good physical health. You have experienced some difficulties with your own mental health following this offence. You have described feeling anxious, stressed and concerned about threats that have been made against you by members of your brother’s family since the offending. I can well understand that is the case, but I hope you recognise that your experience of such things pales into insignificance when compared to what your brother has had to endure since you attacked him. To your credit, you recognise that your alcohol consumption contributed to your conduct on this night. You report reducing your alcohol use to two days a week at which times you will consume drink 3 to 4 standard drinks. At the time of this offending, you report that you were regularly drinking approximately a dozen beers in a sitting. You indicated you would plead guilty to the offence on your first appearance in this Court. The mitigatory effect of your plea of guilty is somewhat muted in the circumstances given the challenges to the factual basis of sentence, but I accept it has saved your brother from being required to give evidence at a trial.
I had you assessed for suitability for home detention and other community-based orders. Community Corrections assessed you as suitable for home detention, however, is concerned about the impact the order would have on you and your family’s health and well-being as it would require you to relocate from Victoria and leave your life with your daughter and granddaughter for a period of time. I am told that you are actively engaged in the care of your granddaughter after school due to her parents’ employment requirements. Community Corrections also expressed concerns regarding your safety if you are to serve a community-based order in Tasmania due to the reports you have made of threats to life and safety, particularly by your nephew. Community Corrections also assessed you as suitable for the imposition of community service on the proviso that you provide positive medical clearance to them prior to sentencing. You are not considered suitable for community-based supervision as you present with limited criminogenic risks and needs. Due to the violent nature of the offending, you have, however, been assessed as suitable for the EQUIPS Aggression program.
This was a serious offence. The impact of your conduct has been devastating on the complainant and to the wider family. Your attack on your brother was brutal and unnecessary. It was, however, committed against a background of significant grief and distress following the death of your mother and increasing disharmony within the family over the management of her estate. I have no doubt your alcohol use was a significant contributing factor to your conduct on this night. That is not a mitigating factor, however, what is significant is that you have taken steps to reduce your alcohol use after reflecting upon your conduct.
The offence of causing grievous bodily harm, particularly in circumstances where the infliction of such harm is intentional, usually attracts a period of imprisonment. What makes your case so unusual is the complete absence of any violent offending in your history. This suggests it was out of character conduct. I have received a number of references from people who speak of your respectful and dependable nature. You are clearly someone who is well thought of in the community and you have made a contribution to it. In those circumstances, personal deterrence assumes less importance than is often the case. However, general deterrence, denunciation of your conduct and vindication of the victim are important factors in this case. I have carefully considered the Community Corrections’ recommendations. In my view, it is necessary to impose a penalty upon you that involves the imposition of some form of immediate punishment in order to properly reflect the matters I have outlined. I consider that, in this case, this can be achieved by imposing a home detention order together with an order requiring you to perform community service. I recognise that you have not yet been medically cleared to perform such community service, but in the event such medical clearance is unable to be obtained, the matter can be brought back before me for review. I accept Community Corrections’ recommendations regarding the conditions of that order. It is my intention that you participate in the EQUIPS Aggression program if possible. But for the option of imposing home detention coupled with community service, I would have imposed a period of imprisonment with a requirement that you immediately serve at least a part of it.
Peter Goss, you are convicted on the indictment charging you with causing grievous bodily harm. You are sentenced to home detention for a period of 12 months. The home detention order takes effect from today.
The terms of the home detention orders will be set out in a written document that will be provided to you. All core conditions of the home detention order will be in force for the operational period of the order. Those core conditions include that you:
- Must not commit an offence that is punishable by imprisonment;
- You must reside at the home detention premises, namely **address**;
- You must be at the home detention premises at all times except between 10:00am to 2:00pm each day, unless with the approval of a probation officer or prescribed officer for particular purposes which will be set out in the order;
- You must comply with any reasonable and lawful directions of a probation officer or prescribed officer, including any directions as to the kind of employment, or the place of employment;
- You must submit to electronic monitoring including by wearing or carrying an electronic device;
- You must, if directed to do so by a police officer, probation officer or prescribed officer, submit to a breath test, urine test, or other test, for the presence of an illicit drug;
- You must, if directed by a probation officer or a prescribed officer to engage in a personal development activity, counselling, or treatment, engage in the activity, counselling or treatment in accordance with any directions given by the probation officer or prescribed officer.
Your home detention order is also subject to the following special conditions during the operational period of the order:
- You must attend the Community Corrections office at Level 1, 75 Liverpool Street, Hobart for induction onto this order during normal business hours and no later than 10:00am tomorrow;
- You must maintain in operating condition an active mobile phone service, provide the contact details to Community Corrections and be accessible for contact through this device at all times;
- You must submit to the supervision of a Community Corrections officer as required by that officer;
- You must not take any illicit or prohibited substances. Illicit and prohibited substances include:
- Any controlled drug as defined by the Misuse of Drugs Act 2001 (Tas);
- Any medication containing an opiate, benzodiazepine, bupropion, hydrochloride or pseudoephedrine unless you provide written evidence from your medical practitioner that you have been prescribed the relevant medication;
- You must not consume alcohol, and you must, if directed to do so by a police officer or Community Corrections officer, submit to a breath test, urine test, or other test, for the presence of alcohol;
- You must not, enter upon or remain upon any licensed premises (excluding cafes, theatres, cinemas and ten-pin bowling venues) unless approved in advance by the probation officer.
In addition, I make a community correction order for a period of 12 months. That order is also subject to a number of core conditions which will be provided to you in writing. They include that you report to a probation officer at the office of Community Corrections at 75 Liverpool Street in Hobart by 10:00am tomorrow. In addition to the core conditions, the order shall also include the special condition that during the period of the order you must satisfactorily perform community service as directed by a probation officer or supervisor for a period of 75 hours.
Mr Goss, if you breach the conditions of either of these orders, or if you commit another offence punishable by imprisonment while those orders are in force, this may result in the matter being brought back to the Court on breach proceedings. Such proceedings could result in the revocation of the order or orders and resentencing, including the imposition of a period of imprisonment.