STATE OF TASMANIA v RILEY JASON CAUSON 10 NOVEMBER 2026
COMMENTS ON PASSING SENTENCE JAGO J
Riley Jason Causon, you were found guilty by jury verdict of one count of aggravated burglary, three counts of aggravated assault and one count of assault. You were found not guilty of two counts of recklessly discharging a firearm. Additionally, I am dealing with your pleas of guilty to related summary charges, being three counts of breach of police family violence order and one count of possess a firearm when not the holder of a firearm licence of the appropriate category.
I note that to the extent the facts do not emerge from the verdicts, it is my responsibility to make findings of fact for sentencing purposes. I may only make finding adverse to you if satisfied beyond reasonable doubt they have been proved, and I may only make findings of fact in your favour if they are proved on the balance of probabilities.
Your offending occurred on 6 January 2024. On that date, you attended the unit of Tahlia Newell. You and Ms Newell had been in a relationship up until December 2023, and it seems in your mind at least, there was some uncertainty as to the state of the relationship. Also, at the unit that day, were two friends of Ms Newell, a Cohen Flannery and Alissa-Jade Stafford. Cohen Flannery was your cousin. I am satisfied your attendance at the unit was prompted by jealousy. You had come to believe Mr Flannery and Ms Newell may have been involved in a relationship. At around 2.30 in the afternoon, you arrived at her unit. You were wearing a balaclava over your face, and you were carrying a firearm. When you arrived, you entered, uninvited, through the rear door and called out to Mr Flannery. You demanded that Mr Flannery come outside. You pointed the gun directly towards Mr Flannery holding it in a position consistent with you intending to fire it. Your finger was on the trigger, and it was pointed directly at him.
I am unable to make a finding beyond reasonable doubt that the firearm was loaded but, in many ways, very little turns on that. The evil of using a firearm to threaten another in this way, is the fear and apprehension it creates. The victim has no way of knowing whether the firearm is loaded or otherwise. Mr Flannery saw your finger on the trigger, and he believed he might die. This constitutes the first count of aggravated assault.
Around the same time, Tahlia Newell tried to intervene and approached you. You pushed her out of the way to pursue Mr Flannery who had retreated further back into the residence. You grabbed hold of Mr Flannery by the hair and started hitting him in the head. You were hitting him with a closed fist. You struck him about four times. This constitutes the crime of assault. You were still holding the firearm as you did this. Again, Tahlia Newell tried to intervene. She approached you from behind and grabbed hold of you to try and pull you off Mr Flannery. In the scuffle, she fell to the floor. You pointed the firearm directly towards her, held it there for a few seconds and said words to the effect of “we are done dog”. This constitutes another crime of aggravated assault.
Around the same time, Alissa-Jade Stafford was standing in the loungeroom area of the unit, and you pointed the firearm towards her. This act constitutes the third count of aggravated assault.
Your actions also breached the police family violence order in various ways, namely; by entering the premises, secondly by assaulting Ms Newell and thirdly, by having possession of a firearm. Your possession of the firearm is also obviously contrary to s 9(1) of the Firearms Act.
As you left the residence through the back door, Ms Newall and Mr Flannery heard a loud bang which they believed was the firearm being discharged. As noted, the jury did not convict you of either count of recklessly discharging a firearm. It is understandable, in my view, that the jury were not satisfied beyond reasonable doubt as to that. Obviously, by this point Ms Newall and Mr Flannery were upset and fearful, and it is entirely feasible that they would assume any loud noise was associated with the firearm. But there was an absence of objective evidence consistent with the firearm being discharged. For example, no discharged ammunition was located when police searched, no neighbours reported hearing gunshots. The absence of corroborative evidence, coupled with the risk that the heightened emotional state of the witnesses might lead to error, rationally explains the jury having a reasonable doubt as to the discharge of the firearm. For the same reasons, I cannot be satisfied the firearm was discharged and therefore cannot be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt it was loaded. There was no other evidence to that effect.
The incident was not immediately reported to police, although Ms Newall told her mother and a friend about your attendance. The following day, however, Ms Stafford who was feeling particularly uneasy about what had happened, contacted police. Subsequent investigations revealed text messages sent to Ms Newall and Mr Flannery, both before and after the incident, which indicated you were the perpetrator. You sent a message to Cohen Flannery threatening him and suggesting you were “coming for him”. After the event, you sent further messages to both Cohen Flannery and Tahlia Newell, indicating your involvement in the matter.
In my view the text messages amounted to compelling evidence that you were the perpetrator. Similarly, the comments made by the perpetrator whilst at the residence to the effect that they were jealous and angry about the alleged relationship between Cohen Flannery and Tahlia Newell, were entirely consistent with you being the perpetrator. I note your defence, in part at least, suggested your twin brother might be to blame for the conduct. The fact that you were prepared to blame your brother in circumstances where the evidence, in my view, overwhelming established that you were the perpetrator says much about your moral standing.
You are nearly 27 years of age. You can no longer be described as a young offender. You have a significant record of prior criminal offending. You were before the youth court for matters of violence and dishonesty. As an adult, you have prior convictions for driving offences, destroy property, matters of dishonesty, matters of violence, matters committed against police and bail offences. Significantly, on 29 November 2019, you were sentenced by this Court for two counts of aggravated robbery. For that matter, you were sentenced to 18 months’ imprisonment, the main of which was suspended on condition that you commit no offence for a period of two years. You subsequently breached that sentencing order and the sentence of imprisonment was activated.
On 22 September 2021, you were sentenced for the crimes of assault and robbery and unlawfully setting fire to property, the latter offence occurring whilst you were in prison in May 2021. Previously imposed periods of suspended imprisonment were activated, with the end result that you were sentenced to an additional 12 months’ imprisonment, cumulative to the sentence you were serving.
You have been sentenced to imprisonment on a number of occasions. That does not appear to have deterred you from ongoing offending. I also note that you have been given the benefit of many sentencing orders directed at encouraging your rehabilitation, again seemingly to little effect. You have regularly breached the terms of suspended periods of imprisonment. You have also breached community service orders.
At the time these crimes were committed, you were on bail from the Magistrates Court for other serious violent offending. On 29 February 2024, you were convicted of matters of common assault and assault a public officer which had occurred in May, July and October 2023. You were before the Magistrates Court in respect of those matters when these crimes occurred. You were subsequently sentenced to imprisonment for a period of six months for that offending. Then in July 2025, you were sentenced to two separate periods of suspended imprisonment, one being for driving offences and the other being for assault a public officer. At that time, there was an application before the Magistrates Court for activation of a period of suspended imprisonment. The sentence was not activated. Then, concerningly in August 2026, you were again before the Magistrates Court for breaches of family violence order and offences contrary to the Firearms Act. In particular, you pleaded guilty to possessing a shortened firearm and possessing ammunition which was suitable for use in that firearm. You also pleaded guilty to possessing a firearm when not the holder of a firearms licence of the appropriate category. It is very concerning that you appear to be a person who can readily access firearms and are willing to be in possession of them despite the existence of court orders, like family violence orders, which prohibit you from possessing the same.
You experienced a difficult childhood. You never knew your biological father. You moved to live with your maternal grandparents from a very young age. You and your twin brother were adopted by them. Excessive consumption of alcohol was common within the broader family. Your grandfather and uncles all consumed alcohol to excess. It often resulted in violence within the home. Your biological mother died when you were 16 years of age. A short time later you lost an elder brother in a motorcycle accident. You struggled to come to terms with the loss of important family members at such a young age. These difficulties were exacerbated when your grandfather passed away in 2021. You were in prison at the time and you were unable to attend your grandfather’s funeral. This was very confronting for you.
I am told that approximately 12 months ago you became a father for the first time. You are now determined to stabilise your life so you can be a positive role model for your child. You and the child’s mother are in a relationship. That relationship has had its difficulties, and at times there has been some uncertainty about the state of the relationship. I am told, however, that you see the relationship as a positive one, and that you wish to pursue it so as to provide some stability for your child, particularly given the type of upbringing you experienced.
Before I was aware of your more recent offending, I had you assessed as to your suitability for home detention. I no longer consider that an appropriate sentencing option. I note, however, the report does indicate that in more recent times you have taken up boxing in an effort to address your anger management difficulties and you seem committed to fatherhood.
Your conduct was very serious indeed. You were clearly in a highly agitated state. You were in a residential area with a firearm. You used that firearm to threaten three people and scare them terribly. I accept the physical violence you inflicted upon Mr Flannery was not to the highest of levels and did not result in any serious injury. The gravamen of your conduct, however, was the fear and intimidation you set out to cause and did, in fact, cause. As I have already indicated, I will sentence giving you the benefit of the doubt in respect to the question of whether the firearm was loaded. But save for the fact it obviously minimises the risk of actual injury from gunshot, it is not of great weight in mitigation. As far as each of the complainants were concerned, you were brandishing a firearm and using it in a very threatening manner. Given your level of agitation, it was reasonable for them to fear it was loaded. The fact it may have been unloaded was of no comfort to them in the moment.
Your crime has had a significant adverse impact upon each of the complainants. I have received impact statements from all of them. Ms Newell speaks of the emotional and psychological trauma she has experienced since the incident. Her sleep has been disturbed. She experiences nightmares. She is now apprehensive about leaving her home and does not feel safe in many social circumstances. She is constantly concerned about her daughter’s safety. She is anxious, hypervigilant and feels emotionally exhausted.
Mr Flannery also speaks of significant psychological trauma. He had pre-existing mental health conditions, which have been exacerbated by your conduct. He too experiences feelings of stress and anxiety and feels constantly on edge. Because you are his cousin, he is concerned about ongoing repercussions within the broader family. He has become socially withdrawn and does not feel he can trust people.
Ms Stafford was pregnant at the time you assaulted her. She experienced considerable upset and anxiety after this incident. particularly in respect to the health of her unborn baby. She has experienced disturbed sleep and is constantly anxious and is now prone to panic attacks. She has become socially withdrawn and remains concerned about her safety. Her broader family relationships have also been affected because her brother is good friends with you and she felt tension and pressure because of that.
To put it simply, your crimes have had a significant, likely long term, adverse impact upon each of the complainants.
In my view, there is very little that mitigates this matter. Society cannot tolerate the unlawful use of firearms to threaten others. You subjected each complainant to a terrifying experience. The only appropriate sentence is a significant term of imprisonment. I will allow for parole but only after you have served a term that sufficiently addresses the need for punishment, deterrence and protection of the public.
Riley Jason Causon, you are convicted of all matters to which you have pleaded guilty. I impose a single sentence. You are sentenced to imprisonment for two years and four months from 8 October 2026. I order that you not be eligible for parole until you have served 18 months of that term.